Law Firm Accused of Misleading Wilmette Voters

In court papers filed against Wilmette School District 39 last week, Taxpayers United of America  (TUA) accused the law firm of Chapman and Cutler of misleading both Wilmette and Oak Park voters into passing property tax increases on April 5 ballots. 

The TUA along with Herbert Sorock filed a brief on June 8 that alleged Chapman and Cutler deliberately used faulty ballot language that made the tax increases for the two towns look less severe. The court challenge started nearly a month ago.

According to the brief, the tax referendums failed to include the state equalizer in explaining how much the rate hikes would effect homeowners. The plaintiffs' attorney, Andrew Spiegel, said this omission was in violation of the state's property tax code and constitution.

In a press release, Chapman and Cutler insists that the Property Tax Extension Limitation Law (PTELL) does not specify a need for the state equalizer in the school districts' ballot propositions.

On Monday, District 39 reiterated that the TUA case was based on a misconstrual of the laws governing the state's ballot language and that the statutes have no actual bearing on the case. 

The school district's response, prepared by attorney Ares Dalianis, also said that even if errors were made, it shouldn't be held liable since any "deliberate" attempts to mislead would be on the part of Chapman and Cutler, not the school district.

The explanatory paragraph in the Wilmette referendum, which passed with 63 percent approval, informed voters that the increase would be $58 for every $1,000 of property taxes paid, or a $58.80 increase for every $100,000 of the estimated value of a home.

According to Spiegel, the cited figure should have been $198.16 for every $100,000.

"If it had been that high, who knows what the vote would have been," he said.

Because Chapman and Cutler served as bond counsel for the school districts in Wilmette and Oak Park, it used the same ballot language in both referendums without mentioning the state equalizer.

TUA tried to consolidate both lawsuits earlier this month. However, the motion was denied by a Cook County judge on June 6.

"The language is exactly the same as Oak Park as in Wilmette," Spiegel said. "It's the exact same problem."

Wilmette Superintendent Ray Lechner worries that if the lawsuit succeeds, District 39 may be placed in "serious financial crisis.

Chapman Law Firm » 2011 Estate Tax Planning – How Will Congress ...

2011 Estate Tax Planning – How Will Congress’ Temporary Tax Act Affect You?

How can you take advantage of the new tax laws in providing gifts and bequests to your loved ones? After years of wrangling and politics, Congress finally acted to increase the estate and gift tax exemption from the prior 2011 schedule of $1 million per person / estate and a 55% rate to $5 million per person / estate with a 35% rate. In the event the $5 million exemption is discontinued, many estate planners believed that, even if the exemption is lowered, those who gifted up to $5 million in 2011-2012 will be “grandfathered” so that they will not owe additional taxes.

For more information as to how you can take advantage of the new tax law affecting your estate planning, please contact us at (248) 644-6326.

West's federal reporter, cases argued and determined in the United States courts of appeals and Temporary Emergency Court of Appeals

Government contract law, the deskbook for procurement professionals

Immigration & nationality law handbook

Vault Guide to Law Firm Diversity Programs

The American bar